Stepping into the world of Schmigadoon! on Broadway is like stepping through a time portal to the Golden Age of live theater. This comedy, inspired by its Apple TV+ predecessor, draws heavily from the 1940s and 1950sa period that the show’s star, Sara Chaseholds in high regard.
Chase’s admiration for this era is evident in her work. She believes that the musical numbers of Schmigadoon! could seamlessly blend with those of the past. This respect for the craft is a key factor in the show’s success. The cast and creative team even visited the Library of Congress in Washington, D.C.where they viewed handwritten notes from legendary lyricists, an experience that deeply moved Chase.
Schmigadoon! on Broadway: A Modern Twist on a Classic Tale
The story of Schmigadoon! unfolds in a magical town where every day is a musical, reminiscent of a bygone era. Chase plays Melissa, one half of a modern-day couple navigating a rocky phase. Alongside Alex Brightmanshe brings to life a tale of love, chaos, and feminism in a dated setting. The show is a blend of Chase’s passions for musicals and comedy, offering her a unique opportunity to showcase her skills.
Chase’s journey to Broadway is a testament to her dedication. Initially believing she was a placeholder, she has since embraced the role and was recently nominated for a Tony Award for Best Actress in a Musical. Her gratitude for this moment is palpable, as she reflects on the privilege of being part of such a rich theatrical history.
The Creative Process Behind Schmigadoon!
Bringing Schmigadoon! to the Broadway stage has been a long and intricate process. Creator Cinco Paul has rewritten, cut, and added new songs to adapt the television show for the stage. This process has been an incredible learning experience, involving the study of Golden Age greats like Rodgers & HammersteinFrank Loesserand Irving Berlin.
Paul emphasizes the importance of rigorous authenticity in pastiche, while also finding a way to put a personal stamp on the work. This approach is evident in the new songs and revamped old ones that make up the Broadway version of Schmigadoon!. From rewriting the opening number to creating new duets, Paul’s work has added depth and authenticity to the show.
Key Songs and Their Inspirations
One of the standout songs in the Broadway version is “Schmigadoon!”which introduces the town and its inhabitants. Paul rewrote the lyrics to highlight the main townsfolk, adding more opportunities for comedy and character development. Another notable song is “You Can’t Tame Me”which has been transformed into a big Gene Kelly-esque showcase for the character Danny Bailey.
The song “Lovers’ Spat” underwent significant changes, with Paul and director Christopher Gattelli trimming it to enhance its impact. Other songs like “The Picnic Basket Auction” and “Not That Kinda Gal” pay homage to classic Rodgers & Hammerstein tunes, adding a layer of nostalgia and authenticity to the show.
The Backstage Experience
For Chase, the backstage experience is just as enchanting as the performance itself. She finds solace in the wig room, where she catches up with her fellow actresses Ana Gasteyer and Izzy McCalla. This space has become a sanctuary for her, a place to connect and share stories with her colleagues.
Chase’s pre-show ritual involves a quiet moment of reflection, where she thanks those who came before her and reminds herself of the privilege of being part of this history. Her day-off hobbies include birdwatching in Central Parka passion that brings her joy and a sense of connection to nature.
Inspired by figure skater Alysa LiuChase’s pre-show playlist ends with “MacArthur Park”a song that reminds her of the joy and inspiration that performance can bring. This mindset is crucial for her, as she believes that performing should be filled with joy, even in the face of anxiety and fear.



